Start with a decision the host can make

Suppose you want to know whether the level you suggest for a first round suits newcomers. As soon as the round ends, ask, “How did the difficulty of that round feel to you?” Offer three boxes: “Easier than I wanted,” “About right for me,” and “Harder than I wanted.” Players can leave the card blank.

A round can be hard and enjoyable at the same time. Someone who liked the challenge can choose “About right for me.” Asking whether the game was “easy and fun” would hide that distinction.

Decide who gets a card

Set aside a trial period. Offer one card to everyone who finishes their first round at the suggested level during that period, including players who head straight for the exit or miss every stick. Keep a tally of invitations. The level and the answer are enough to analyse this question; you can leave names and phone numbers off the card.

Report the count alongside the answers

Here is a hypothetical example. You invite 20 players and 12 answer. Seven say the round was harder than they wanted, four say it felt right and one wanted more of a challenge. In the stand log, write “Seven of the 12 respondents found this round harder than they wanted. Eight people gave no answer.” Those eight players’ preferences are unknown.

Use the answers to offer a choice

With a result like this, try making the choice between an easier start and your usual suggested level clearer before the next session. Keep the question the same and count the responses for each level separately. If the pattern changes, remember that players now choose their own level. The difference can inform your planning, but it cannot establish how much the level itself changed anyone’s experience.

Sources & further reading

Educational content prepared with AI assistance and the sources listed. Confirm the specifications of each model with its manufacturer.

Discover Catch Stick